I think the difference here is that the Neutrogena eye perfector starts off creamy but then dries down, whereas most other concealers I've tried stay creamy, which pretty much guarentees they are going to migrate into any available crevice or line. The Neutrogena perfector settles slightly, but a quick pat removes the problem, leaving me with a brightened eye area that is also protected by the SPF25 in the product. That's another feature that I like, as I don't think any of the other eye products I use contain SPF.
Another plus is that not only is this a brightener, but it is also contains a patented blend of anti-oxidants including Vitamin E, wild chamomile and soy to help de-puff and treat the appearance of dark under eye circles.
|Neutrogena Brightening Eye Perfector in Fair|
The price is about $13, and ULTA currently has a BOGO 50% off deal on Neutrogena products. I'm very happy to have discovered this!
Disclosure: I purchased this.